25 Best Baptism Gifts to Celebrate Their Blessing
Every editorial product is independently selected, though we may be compensated or receive an affiliate commission if you buy something through our links. Ratings and prices are accurate and items are in stock as of time of publication.
Find sweet baptism gifts for girls and boys, plus gender-neutral ideas too!
A baptism is certainly a milestone to celebrate. And with that celebration comes the need for a special gift. If you’re a grandparent or godparent looking for the perfect baptism gift idea, something unique, personalized or handmade is sure to bring a smile.
From Noah’s Ark toy sets to cross pendants and personalized date prints, these baptism gifts for boys, girls and gender-neutral options will serve as a sweet, sentimental way to commemorate the occasion.
Planning a celebration? Be sure to consider these tasty baptism party recipes.
Best Baptism Gifts for Boys
Personalized Baptism Date Print
Commemorate the special day with a personalized print from Etsy. Choose your size, add the child’s name and the baptism date. Once it’s received, frame the print to serve as the perfect piece of wall art for years to come.
Noah’s Ark Toy Set
This Pottery Barn toy set is not only adorable, but it also fits the baptism theme. Made from solid birch wood, it’s easy to play with and brings the story of Noah’s Ark to life. How cute are the matching set of zebras?
Personalized Sailboat Box
This simple Etsy clay sailboat box is as sweet as can be. Select a cross, an anchor or another graphic to go under their name, along with other personalized details. As they grow, they can use the box as a place to stash their favorite treasures.
Boys Crib Shoes
Make sure the man of the hour is dressed to impress for the baptism. These little booties from Nordstrom are so charming as a pre-baptism gift and can be worn again and again.
A baptism is an occasion to dress up for, after all. This adorable romper from Etsy is the perfect outfit, complete with a symbolic cross detailing.
Guardian Angel Sculpture
Give the gift of a guardian angel for a baptized boy. Carved out of resin and hand painted, this Willow Tree guardian angel sculpture is the ideal trinket to set on a dresser or nightstand to watch over him.
Baptism Photo Frame
Commemorate his special day with this Precious Moments baptism photo frame. It’s the perfect size for displaying a 4×6 photo, and it includes the sentiment “Cradled In His Love.”
Keep your little ones occupied with this keepsake baptism block. Available on Etsy, this sweet gift includes details on every side, including his name, the date, a bible verse, image and more.
Best Baptism Gifts for Girls
Personalized Baptism Book
Make bedtime extra special with this personalized baptism book from Etsy. Not only does it include your child’s name, but it features a variety of daily blessings in an adorable, illustrated format.
Gold Cross Pendant
It’s never too soon for a gorgeous piece of jewelry, and this gold cross necklace for toddlers is the perfect fit. Celebrate a beautiful baptism with 14-karat gold that will turn into a family heirloom. Pick it up at Nordstrom.
Girls Baptism Shoes
Is there anything sweeter than little white baby shoes? These crib shoes from Nordstrom are perfect for a baptism, with beautiful, embroidered detailing and an adorable, scalloped trim. Plus, the strap is adjustable for easy on and off.
Personalized Name Puzzle
A personalized gift goes a long way, and this Etsy wooden name puzzle is the ideal surprise for a little lady. Add in a name while ordering, and this handmade wooden puzzle will show up beautifully painted and ready to be played with, just in time to serve as a baptism gift.
Personalized Baptism Print
Celebrate a baptism with an adorable piece of wall art for her nursery. This baptism name print from Etsy comes in a variety of sizes, with the option to add in the child’s name and the baptism date to make it a truly one-of-a-kind baptism gift.
The cross shape and personalized beads make this modern wooden rattle from Etsy a sweet baptism gift. The pastel hues are incredibly charming, too.
Baptism Night Light
Your little one will love the soothing glow of this night light from Etsy. Customized with their name, date and even a favorite bible verse, this personalized baptism gift is sentimental and practical. Choose from six styles, including two cross-shaped options.
Best Gender-Neutral Baptism Gifts
Commemorate the special occasion with a new, special outfit. This gender-neutral onesie from Etsy is great for a little boy or little girl who has just been baptized and is ready to make their debut. Here are even more fantastic gift ideas.
Personalized Piggy Bank
It’s never too early to start a piggy bank, and the little one in your life will have so much fun with this Etsy baptism gift. Personalize this handmade, wooden bank with a name and select the perfect color palette to create a truly treasured gift.
Bless the child with a lovely lamb plush from Pottery Barn. But this isn’t just any other stuffed animal. This sweet lamb plays soothing sounds to lull your little one to sleep.
This prayer jar from Precious Moments is adorable on its own. But it becomes a treasured baptism gift when filled with well wishes from loved ones.
Personalized Dove Ornament
No matter what time of year your child is baptized, you’ll want to commemorate the occasion on the family’s Christmas tree. We love this polished silver dove ornament etched with a name, date and special message. Pick up this baptism gift from Personalization Mall.
The intricacy of this personalized alphabet canvas is truly incredible, especially as it brings Christian artwork into the mix. Choose the mat color, frame and specifics such as hair color for a truly personalized name print that’s a perfect baptism gift for boys or girls. Order it on Etsy.
A personalized baptism quilt from Etsy is both pretty and practical. This darling gift—stitched with your little one’s details—makes for memorable baptism photos and provides warmth in a chilly chapel.
Wooden Nativity Set
It’s never too early to start teaching the Christmas story! This Pottery Barn wooden nativity set is recommended for kids ages two and up, so you can use it as seasonal nursery decor until your little one is old enough to play.
Baby’s First Bible
Of course, a Bible is one of the classic baptism gifts. But this hardcover children’s book of Bible stories from Amazon takes the idea to a new level of special. With super colorful illustrations, plus padding to keep the book kid appropriate, this is the ideal introduction to bible stories.
Musical Snow Globe
Baby will sleep easy when drifting off to this snow globe’s “Jesus Loves Me” hymn. Other adorable details, like a bear and blanket, complete this sweet Precious Moments baptism gift.